Winchester 400 vs. Remington 360 Buckhammer: A Deep Dive into the Newest Straight-Wall Rifle Cartridges

by Danny Reed November 21, 2024

For hunters in states that require straight-wall rifle cartridges for deer hunting, innovation is exciting—and 2024 has delivered with the introduction of two brand-new options: the Winchester 400 and the Remington 360 Buckhammer. Both calibers have sparked plenty of conversation, with hunters eager to see how these cartridges stack up in performance, accuracy, and overall utility in the field.

If you’re considering upgrading your deer rifle or looking for the perfect straight-wall cartridge for the upcoming season, this article will break down the performance, pros and cons, and key considerations of both calibers. While we won’t declare a clear winner, we’ll provide the information you need to make an informed choice for your hunting needs.

What Are Straight-Wall Rifle Cartridges?

Before diving into the specifics, let’s quickly revisit why straight-wall cartridges have become popular in states like Iowa, Michigan, and Ohio. These cartridges are legal in certain areas where bottlenecked cartridges are not, offering hunters a modern firearm option with improved range and accuracy over shotguns. The focus is on delivering a reliable, ethical harvest in regions with safety restrictions due to population density.

Winchester 400: Power Meets Versatility

Winchester’s entry into the straight-wall market, the Winchester 400, is engineered for performance at mid-to-long ranges within the constraints of straight-wall regulations. This cartridge offers excellent energy retention, making it a top choice for hunters who value stopping power.

Performance Highlights:

• Muzzle Velocity: The Winchester 400 is designed for higher velocities compared to earlier straight-wall options, with speeds exceeding 2,200 fps, depending on bullet weight.
• Energy Transfer: With substantial energy on impact, this cartridge delivers impressive knockdown power, ensuring clean and ethical kills.
• Ballistic Efficiency: A relatively flat trajectory for a straight-wall cartridge makes it effective at ranges up to 250 yards.

Pros:

• Extended Range: Its flatter trajectory and higher velocity make it ideal for hunters who want to stretch their effective range without compromising accuracy.
• Bullet Variety: Winchester has introduced a range of bullet weights and designs to cater to different hunting scenarios, from heavy brush to open fields.

Cons:

• Recoil: The added power comes with increased recoil, which might be a factor for newer or recoil-sensitive hunters.
• Availability: As a new cartridge, ammo availability may initially be limited in some areas.

Remington 360 Buckhammer: A Traditional Yet Modern Take

The Remington 360 Buckhammer is designed with a focus on compatibility and ease of use, making it a strong choice for lever-action rifle enthusiasts. Its name pays homage to the classic hunting experience, blending modern ballistics with a nod to traditional hunting culture.

Performance Highlights:

• Muzzle Energy: With muzzle energy comparable to the .35 Remington, the 360 Buckhammer excels at delivering hard-hitting performance at moderate ranges.
• Range: Effective out to 200 yards, this cartridge shines in wooded areas and typical deer hunting distances.
• Lever-Action Friendly: The Buckhammer was specifically designed to work seamlessly in lever-action rifles, a favorite among many hunters.

Pros:

• Lower Recoil: Compared to the Winchester 400, the Buckhammer offers a softer recoil, making it a great option for hunters of all experience levels.
• Compatibility: Its design caters to hunters using traditional rifles, particularly those who favor lever-action firearms.
• Cost-Effective: Early indications suggest that the 360 Buckhammer may be more affordable, both in ammunition price and rifle selection.

Cons:

• Range Limitations: While effective, its range and trajectory are slightly more limited compared to the Winchester 400, potentially making it less versatile in open fields.
• Ammo Options: With fewer bullet weights available at launch, hunters may find the initial offerings less diverse.

How to Choose Between the Winchester 400 and Remington 360 Buckhammer

Both cartridges are impressive and cater to different types of hunters and hunting scenarios. Here are some factors to consider when choosing between the two:

1. Hunting Environment:
• If you hunt in open terrain where longer shots are common, the flatter trajectory of the Winchester 400 might be advantageous.
• For thick woods or shorter ranges, the 360 Buckhammer’s design is perfectly suited to the task.
2. Rifle Preference:
• The Winchester 400 is a great fit for hunters using modern rifles optimized for precision and extended range.
• If you prefer the classic feel of a lever-action rifle, the Remington 360 Buckhammer is the clear choice.
3. Recoil Sensitivity:
• Hunters who are sensitive to recoil or are introducing younger shooters to the sport may appreciate the softer recoil of the 360 Buckhammer.
4. Availability and Budget:
• Keep an eye on ammo availability and pricing in your area. While both cartridges are new, regional supply and demand may influence your decision.

Conclusion: A Win-Win for Hunters

The introduction of the Winchester 400 and the Remington 360 Buckhammer represents an exciting advancement in straight-wall rifle cartridges. Both options offer unique advantages, and neither is inherently better—it all comes down to your personal hunting style, preferences, and the conditions in which you hunt.

Share:

---

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Name *

Email *

Comment *

---

Also in Follow Along on Hardy Facepaint's Hunting Adventures